{
  "date": "2026-09-13",
  "kind": "sanitized-validation-summary",
  "scopeNote": "Historical evidence before subsequent portal/control fixes and real-generation follow-up; not final regression evidence for the newer UI",
  "followUpEvidence": "external-knowledge-follow-up-2026-09-13.json",
  "sources": [
    "kb-strict-validation/report.json",
    "kb-desktop-ui-validation-20260913/report.json",
    "goodbuddy-native-controls-fix-full.log",
    "goodbuddy-native-controls-fix-full.result.json"
  ],
  "automatedChecks": {
    "status": "passed-before-subsequent-ui-follow-up",
    "authoritativeCounts": "progress.md",
    "fullApp": { "status": "passed", "evidence": "owner handoff" },
    "fullSuite": {
      "command": "npm test -- --maxWorkers=1 --reporter=verbose",
      "status": "passed",
      "exitCode": 0,
      "evidence": ["goodbuddy-native-controls-fix-full.log", "goodbuddy-native-controls-fix-full.result.json"]
    },
    "typecheck": { "command": "npm run typecheck", "status": "passed", "evidence": "owner handoff after final code edits" },
    "lint": { "command": "npm run lint", "status": "passed", "evidence": "owner handoff after final code edits" },
    "diffCheck": { "status": "passed", "evidence": "owner handoff after final code edits" },
    "sourceStability": {
      "files": ["src/renderer/src/App.tsx", "src/renderer/src/App.test.tsx"],
      "hashesStableThroughoutFullRun": true,
      "evidence": "owner handoff"
    },
    "priorFailures": "resolved; exact intermediate and final counts are maintained only in progress.md"
  },
  "strictService": {
    "boundary": "Production KnowledgeService/client and local HTTP MCP in real Electron; no interactive renderer or authenticated Linux execution",
    "electronVersion": "43.2.0",
    "safeStorageAvailable": true,
    "safeStorageRoundTrip": true,
    "retrievalHttpAttempts": 12,
    "retrievalHttpResponses": 12,
    "profiles": [
      { "provider": "dify", "profile": 1, "scheme": "https:", "strictTls": true, "catalogPassed": true, "detailHttpStatus": 405, "bindingPassed": true, "persistedCredentialReopened": true, "responseSchemaValid": true, "retrievalResults": 0, "mcpToolSuccess": true, "mcpReferences": 0, "citationMappingValid": true, "retrievalHttpAttempts": 3 },
      { "provider": "dify", "profile": 2, "scheme": "https:", "strictTls": true, "catalogPassed": true, "detailHttpStatus": 200, "bindingPassed": true, "persistedCredentialReopened": true, "responseSchemaValid": true, "retrievalResults": 2, "mcpToolSuccess": true, "mcpReferences": 2, "citationMappingValid": true, "retrievalHttpAttempts": 3 },
      { "provider": "fastgpt", "profile": 1, "scheme": "https:", "strictTls": true, "catalogPassed": true, "detailHttpStatus": 200, "bindingPassed": true, "persistedCredentialReopened": true, "responseSchemaValid": true, "retrievalResults": 2, "mcpToolSuccess": true, "mcpReferences": 2, "citationMappingValid": true, "retrievalHttpAttempts": 3 },
      { "provider": "ragflow", "profile": 1, "scheme": "http:", "strictTls": null, "catalogPassed": true, "detailHttpStatus": 200, "bindingPassed": true, "persistedCredentialReopened": true, "responseSchemaValid": true, "retrievalResults": 1, "mcpToolSuccess": true, "mcpReferences": 1, "citationMappingValid": true, "retrievalHttpAttempts": 3 }
    ]
  },
  "desktop": {
    "provider": "dify",
    "phase": "completed",
    "boundary": "Production electron-vite Main, preload, BrowserWindow, renderer and IPC; existing provider key substituted in Main at instance-save handler boundary",
    "callsByKind": { "catalog": 4, "detail": 4, "retrieval": 6 },
    "totalReadOnlyCalls": 14,
    "allHttpStatus200": true,
    "checks": [
      "Instance saved through production IPC",
      "Catalog selected and binding saved after live retrieval",
      "Persisted binding reopened in isolated desktop profile",
      "Local parameters saved through production binding update",
      "Native ArrowRight moved focus and activated retrieval tab",
      "Live search references persisted and reopened in production citation dialog"
    ],
    "measuredViewportWidths": [1439, 899, 699],
    "bodyOverflowAtMeasuredWidths": [0, 0, 0],
    "configColumnsAtMeasuredWidths": { "1439": 2, "699": 1 },
    "mobileListVisible": true,
    "savedCommonConfig": { "resultLimit": 2, "requestTimeoutMs": 15000, "maxSnippetCharacters": 200 },
    "resultCount": 2,
    "localContextButtons": false,
    "window": { "sandbox": true, "contextIsolation": true, "nodeIntegration": false },
    "encryptedCredential": { "scheme": "electron-safe-storage", "decryptMatches": true, "plaintextAbsent": true },
    "citationPersisted": { "count": 1, "referenceCount": 2 },
    "citationDialog": { "snapshot": true, "provider": true, "snippet": true, "openSource": false, "focusInside": true },
    "citationMethod": "Production knowledge.search returned live references; harness saved a labeled test transcript through conversations.saveLocal and opened it after reload. No model answer generated",
    "isolatedProfileAndBuildRemoved": true
  },
  "remote": {
    "lanTcpConnected": true,
    "vpnTcpConnected": true,
    "savedCredentialSource": "unreadable",
    "hostKeyState": "verified",
    "blocker": "E_SAFE_STORAGE_DECRYPT_FAILED",
    "forcedPreflightLive": "blocked-before-authenticated-ssh",
    "authenticatedSshAttempts": 0
  },
  "sessionAccounting": {
    "source": "Strict report historical bounds plus desktop report; confirmed by owner handoff",
    "unsurfacedFirstPassRetrievalMinimum": 0,
    "unsurfacedFirstPassRetrievalMaximum": 12,
    "earlierConfirmedRetrievalCalls": 12,
    "strictRetrievalCalls": 12,
    "desktopRetrievalCalls": 6,
    "totalRetrievalMinimum": 30,
    "totalRetrievalMaximum": 42,
    "generatedModelAnswers": 0,
    "limitation": "First pass retained no diagnostics, so its exact retrieval count cannot be reconstructed. Provider-side embedding, reranking and audit usage is not counted as generated answers"
  }
}